Analysts fear rush to impeach Trump henchmen is a trap

Analysts fear rush to impeach Trump henchmen is a trap
Donald Trump gestures at Turning Point USA's AmericaFest in Phoenix, Arizona, U.S., December 22, 2024. REUTERS/Cheney Orr/File Photo
Donald Trump gestures at Turning Point USA's AmericaFest in Phoenix, Arizona, U.S., December 22, 2024. REUTERS/Cheney Orr/File Photo
Bank

As Democrats prepare to reclaim control of Congress, there is a growing movement for them to impeach President Donald Trump's top officials like Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth.

"The morning of the impeachment vote, Hegseth held a news conference, his first in six months, portraying the attempt to oust him as an assault on the President and the troops," reported The New Yorker's Ruth Marcus on Sunday. "'This is not patriotism—this is sabotage,' he said. After the vote, through a spokesman, Hegseth declared 'total victory,' while Trump lauded the 'EXONERATION of a Great American Patriot.' But, as anyone who has watched Trump understands, his loud professions of support are good for that moment only—a particular risk for Hegseth given the unpopularity of the war."

Marcus continued, "And the Democrats seem in no mood to back off when they take over in January, if they still have Hegseth to kick around then. Hakeem Jeffries, the incoming Speaker of the House, has declared himself a 'hard yes' on Hegseth’s impeachment."

Yet Marcus had a warning for these Democrats — impeachments could politically backfire.

"Come January, oversight and its offspring, accountability, will be essential. Democrats will have a chance—despite how much Trump will resist—to document his Administration’s cruelty, incompetence, and corruption, not just for the historical record but to understand how such behavior can be stopped," Marcus wrote. "The range of seeming malfeasance is staggering: granting pay-to-play pardons, issuing no-bid contracts, exploiting government service to amass enormous personal wealth. Then there are questions of policy, such as the Administration’s treatment of immigrant detainees and its dealings with Nvidia."

She continued, "Democrats must exercise their power with caution. For the new majority, the next two years will entail navigating the tension between holding the Trump Administration accountable for its actions and delivering tangible results for voters. In the case of impeaching Hegseth, the process is unlikely to succeed. Even with the Democrats’ fifty-six-seat Senate majority, removing him would require eleven Republican votes. Pursuing an effort destined to end in defeat could make the Democrats appear fixated on administering political payback rather than addressing voters’ pressing financial concerns. The damage could be mitigated, though, if Hegseth is the only official whom they attempt to remove. Another failed impeachment of Trump would merely help him play the victim."

Hegseth is a historically unpopular Pentagon leader, especially within the Pentagon itself, where he has conducted mass purges of military officers.

"Since January 2025," Michael N. Schmitt, a law professor at New York University, wrote for Just Security earlier this month. "the Defense Department has removed, replaced, or forced the early retirement of a remarkable concentration of operationally experienced senior officers. Among them are the chairman of the Joint Chiefs, the chief of naval operations, the chief of staff of the Army, and the commander of U.S. Cyber Command, who concurrently serves as director of the National Security Agency. Most recently, Gen. Christopher Donahue, one of the most decorated and combat-experienced officers of his generation, has been forced out as commander of U.S. Army Europe and Africa and, in his NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization) role, as commander of Allied Land Command. Public explanations have been sparse and, to the extent they have been offered, largely general."

{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}
@2026 - AlterNet Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. - "Poynter" fonts provided by fontsempire.com.